Hello, Dolly! film on DVD

There is a bit of lore in my family. Before my parents were parents, they would occassionally go to downtown Detroit to see a Broadway touring show. In late 1963 they went down to the Fisher Theatre to see a new show before it opened on Broadway. They left the theater after the performance liking the show very much but thinking the woman who played the lead was very odd and would never have any kind of career. That woman was Carol Channing and that show was Hello, Dolly! So, I come from a line of opinionated people who are often wrong.

That said, I really dislike the film version of this very likable show. While I am usually the last person to blame an actor, I really do think this film is mostly badly cast. The men in particular are not much fun to listen to when they are singing. Yes, even Michael Crawford who will go on to have a much lauded career. I think the songs don't suit his singing voice. And Walter Matthau. Don't get me started.

But, this is a great show for the chorus, with many lively group numbers. And with Gene Kelly as the director of this film, you know that dance will play an important part. That's good to see. And the outdoor locations are spectacular--clearly no expense was sparred in recreating 19th Century New York and Yonkers.

Hello, Dolly!
Music and Lyrics by Jerry Herman
Book by Michael Stewart
1969 film directed by Gene Kelly
Cast: Barbra Streisand, Walter Matthau, Michael Crawford, Tommy Tune, Marianne McAndrew, Joyce Ames, Danny Lockin, Louis Armstrong, EJ Peaker

Turn of the Century live performance at the Goodman Theatre

The last live musical performance I saw at the Goodman Theatre was Ain't Misbehavin', which I very much liked, so I was looking forward to a new musical play from the Goodman, featuring selections from the Great American Songbook in a production directed and choreographed by Tommy Tune, starring Broadway veteran Rachel York and film good-guy Jeff Daniels. But Turn of the Century was a disappointment from beginning to end when I saw it over the weekend.

This is basically a show that gets in the way of a lot of good music. The show tells the story of a pianist and a singer who get sent back one hundred years and make a name for themselves by "writing" many of the song standards that have yet to be written. We hear many of the most recognizable songs of the last one hundred years, usually in snippets.

Rather than a love story for the ages, this is a love story that takes ages. As my theater-going companion pointed out, there is no chemistry between Mr. Daniels and Ms. York, and while the later sings admirably in the several full songs she is given, often-times the over-blown arrangements get in the way. Mr. Daniels displays little of the charm that is his trademark on film. And while he is often very animated (particularly while miming playing the piano), he seems to just be being himself most of the time, which doesn't really reach very strongly across the footlights.

Joining these two on stage is an ensemble of 16 Chicago-based actors who back-up the two leads, but are given very little time in the spotlight themselves. One of the few times an ensemble member steps front and center is when Kevin Gudahl, as Harry Van Deusen the leading songwriter of 1900, sings one of the few original songs in the score--about Mr. Daniels getting his comeuppance and being outed as a fraud. Mr. Gudahl is an accomplished Chicago actor whom I have seen in mostly classical plays at Chicago Shakespeare Theatre. He can really sell it when called for--something Mr. Daniels should learn.

With the star-studded cast (well at least studded with two), a brand-name director, and a book by Brickman and Elice (of Jersey Boys fame), I'm sure this was pegged to transfer to Broadway following this try-out in Chicago. Dare I say without a much better book, better musical arrangements, and perhaps even a new lead to two, I think this show will not see the light of day after is goes dark in Chicago.

Turn of the Century

Music by everyone from Irving Berlin to Barry Manilow
Lyrics by the same
Book by Marshall Brickman and Rick Elice
Directed by Tommy Tune
Presented at the Goodman Theatre in Chicago through November 2
Cast: Jeff Daniels, Rachel York, Ron Orbach, Rachel de Benedet, Kevin Gudahl, Rebecca Finnegan, Johah Rawitz